My wife and I stayed in cottage 2, just last week. We scored on the weather! Mid-50°’s in January?! Crazy. Plus there was no wind and the water was so calm. Even if it was a stormy two days, we would have enjoyed our time on Lopez. The cottages are great. Clean, comfortable and quiet. Going on the off season, we pretty much had the place to ourselves. The only hiccup we had was that I had reserved a specific cottage and they put us in another one in the system. Not a big deal, but I wanted cottage 2 and everything got worked out. Be sure to check before you go, if it matters to you. It was probably just a fluke. The only other thing, had we known they didn’t have a drip coffee maker we would have brought one with us. The French press was fine though. I don’t mean to be picky. Just an fyi! We’ll be back for sure.