It is difficult to rate the rooms, since they are very rustic, but that's the vibe here. The location is great and you are right on the beach. You are never far from anywhere on Orcas Island, so I give the location 5 stars due to the proximity to the water and fact that you are facing west so get sunsets over the Pacific. I may have given the rooms four stars instead of three had the beds been more comfortable; however, while the bed in our main room was okay, the other bed and the futon were rough. Had we been staying with anyone else, they would likely not have been happy (a small child may have been okay).
The service was great and all the staff were very friendly. The other guests kept to themselves but no one was rude.
Overall, were I to go back to Orcas I would consider staying here again. The pictures are of our cabin and the view from the beach. I will say that there are cabins scattered all around. If you want a cabin on the beach, make sure to pick one on the map correctly.