My wife and I stayed in Cabin #4 in the end of August.
Pros: The owners were nice and helpful. This is always a plus.
The cabin was rustic, not frilly. We enjoyed it - clean and comfortable and had what we needed.
The country around the area is beautiful - it's over 10,000 feet so it was cool at nights. There is fishing access to the Conejos River along Forest Rd 250 (the road you come in from coming from Chama).
Cons: It's hard to tell from the pics but the cabin is not near the river. We had to drive to it to fish.
There was no nice porch or sitting area outside our cabin. There were picnic tables outside but they weren't shaded. Besides a single plastic chair there was no outside furniture to sit on. The views of the mountains was limited to ones covered with trees so there was no wildlife viewing from the cabin area.
We had a good time there and I would recommend this place as long as it is understood what the area is like.